The theoretical and methodological bases of the institution of restrictions in the system of individual’s legal status
Keywords:
Human rights and freedoms, civil rights and freedoms, institution of restrictions, elements of the institution of the restrictions on rights and freedoms.
Abstract
The paper analyzes the notional, historical, theoretical and methodological elements in the structure of the legal institution of the restrictions on human and civil rights and freedoms in the context of modern scientific views. It formulates the theoretical basis for this legal institution by comprehending the scientific knowledge and the system of appropriate legal norms compared to the international and European legal norms and legal provisions of similar institutions in the foreign countries. The authors examine the essence and purpose of the institution of restrictions in the system of legal regulation. They analyze the terminology of the institution under study and reveal its challenges. Besides, they offer to specify the basic terms and notions used to regulate legal relationships in this area. The analysis enables the authors to define various elements of the institution. Besides, they introduce terminological specifications for some of them. In particular, they define lawful restrictions and arrange them in a fine system of absolute and relative restrictions on human and civil rights and freedoms. The authors make a conclusion that absolute limitations should be introduced only in case of a specific situation (martial law or emergency state). They take into account that these situations are treated as self-sufficient and unique.
Downloads
Download data is not yet available.
References
Avakyan S.А. Konstitutsionnoe Pravo Rossii. (2010). Russia’s Constitutional Law, An academic course. Moscow. Yurist, 693 p.
Belomestnyh L.L. Ogranichenie Prav i Svobod Cheloveka i Grazhdanina: Teoreticheskiy Aspekt. (2003). The Restrictions on Human Rights and Freedoms: a Theoretical Aspect. An PhD thesis (Law). Мoscow, 197 p.
Chetvernin V.А. Konstitutsiya Rossiyskoi Federatsii. Problemnyi Kommentariy. (2007). The Constitution of the Russian Federation. Comments to Difficult Points. Мoscow, 2007. 596 p.
Denisenko V.V. Legitimnost kak Kharakteristika Suschnosti Prava. Vvedenie v Teoriyu. (2014). Legitimacy as a Characteristic of the Essence of Law. Introduction to Theory. A monograph. Мoscow. Yurlitinform, 258 p.
Dolzhikov A.V. Kriterii Dopustimosti Ogranicheniya Osnovnykh Prav Cheloveka i Grazhdanina v Rossiyskoi Federatsii. (2003). The Admissibility Criteria of the Restrictions on Basic Human and Civil Rights in the Russian Federation. A PhD thesis (Law). Tyumen, 201 p.
Ebzeev B.S. Printsypy, Predely, Osnovaniya Ogranicheniya Prav i Svobod Chelovela po Rossiyskomu Zakonodatelstvu i Mezhdunarodnomu Pravu. (1998). Principles, Limits and Bases of the Restrictions on Human Rights and Freedoms in Russian Legislation and International Law. Gosudarstvoi Pravo. No 8. – Pp. 24-28.
Goiman V.I. Printsypy, Predely, Osnovaniya Ogranicheniya Prav i Svobod Cheloveka po Rossiyskomu Zakonodatelstvu i Mezhdunarodnomu Pravu. (1998). Principles, Limits and Bases of the Restrictions on Human Rights and Freedoms in Russian Legislation and International Law. Gosudarstvoi Pravo. No 8. Pp. 26-29.
Istomin V.T. Printsypy, Predely, Osnovaniya Ogranicheniya Pravi Svobod Chelovelai Grazhdaninapo Rossiyskomu i Mezhdunarodnomu Pravu. (2008). Principles, Limits and Bases of the Restrictions on Human and Civil Rights and Freedoms in Russian and International Law. The proceedings of the round table in the journal GosudarstvoiPravo. GosudarstvoiPravo, No 7. Pp. 26-33.
KabrievaT.Ya., Chirkin V.E. Teoriya Sovremennoi Konstitutsii. (2005). A Theory of Modern Constitution. Moscow. Norma, 237 p.
Kistyakovskiy B.A. V Zaschitu Prava. (1991). Defending Law (Intelligentsia and Legal Awareness). Vekhi: SbornikStatey o RusskoiIntelligentsii [Landmarks: A Collection of Papers about Russian Intellectuals]. Moscow. Pravda, Pp. 122-149
KonstitutsionnyePrava v Rossii, DelaiResheniya, (2002). Constitutional Rights in Russia: Cases and Decisions, A tutorial. Edited by А. Shaio. Мoscow, 459 p.
Lapaeva V.V. Problema Ogranicheniya Prav i Svobod Cheloveka i Grazhdanina v Konstitutsii RF. (2005). The Restrictions on Human Rights and Freedoms in the RF Constitution. Zhurnal Rossiyskogo Prava, No 7. Pp. 13-18.
Lebedeva E.N. Pravostimuliruyushaya Politika v Sovremennoi Rossii: Obscheteoreticheskiy Aspekt. (2014). The Policy of Legal Stimulation in Modern Russia: General Theoretical Aspect. Edited by A.V. Malko. Saratov. The publishing House of the Saratov State Academy of Law, 2014. 367 p.
Lepeshkin A.I. Pravovoe Polozhenie Sovetskikh Grazhdan. (1966). Legal Status of Soviet Citizens, Мoscow, 159 p.
Malinovskaya V.M. Pravomernoe Ogranicheniye Konstitutsionnyh Prav i Svobod Cheloveka i Grazhdanina v Rossiyskoi Federatsii. (2007). A Lawful Restriction on Human and Civil Rights and Freedoms in the RF. Мoscow, 217 p.
Malko A.V. Stimulyi Ogranicheniya v Prave. (1994). Stimuli and Restrictions in Law. Saratov, 259 p.
Matuzov N.I. Lichnost. Prava. Demokratiya: Teoreticheskie ProblemySubyektivnogo Prava. (1972). Personality. Rights. Democracy: Theoretical issues of the Subjective Law, Saratov, Pp. 189 - 205.
Nersesyants V.S. Progress v Prave, (1995). Progress if Law (historical experience и perspectives). Moscow. BEK, 1995. 302 p.
Novikova I.V. Sudebnay aZaschitakak Garantiya Realizatsii Konstitutsionnogo Pravana Mestnoe Samoupravlenie. (2004). Legal Defense as a Guarantee of a Constitutional Right on Local Self-government. A PhD thesis (Law). Voronezh. 2004. 191p.
NurmagombetovR.G. Konstitutsionno-Pravovye Zaprety i Ogranicheniya. (2007). Constitutional and Legal Prohibitions and Restrictions. An abstract of a PhD thesis (Law). Chelyabinsk, 33 p.
Pchelintsev S.V. Kontseptualnye Podkhody k Formirovaniyu Teorii Ogranicheniya PraviSvobod Grazhdanna Sovremennom Etape. (2006). Conceptual Approaches to the Development of the Theory of the Restrictions on Rights and Freedoms of Citizens at Modern Stage. Konstitutsionnoe I MunitsipalnoePravo, No 5. Pp. 23-29.
Pereverzev A.A. Osnovaniya Ogranicheniya Konstitutsionnyh Prav i Svobod Cheloveka i Grazhdanina v RF. (2006). The Bases for Restricting Human and Civil Rights and Freedoms in the RF.. An abstract of a PhD thesis (Law). Rostov-on-Don, 2006. 31 p.
Podmarev A.A. KontseptsiyanOgranicheniyanPrav i Svobod Chelovekai Grazhdanina v Konstitutsii Rossiyskoi Federatsii. (2011). The Concept of Restrictions on Human and Civil Rights and Freedoms in the RF Constitution, Moscow. Status, 329 p.
Pravai Svobody Cheloveka i Grazhdanina v Rossiyskoi Federatsii. (2005). Human and Civil Rights and Freedoms in the Russian Federation. Edited by Professor O.I. Tiunov, Doct.Sc. (Law). Moscow. Norma, 532p.
Romashova I.P. Legitimnost kak Kognitivno-Pragmaticheskaya Diskursivnaya Kategoriya. (2013). Legitimacy as a Cognitive and Pragmatic Category of Discourse. Bulletin of Chelyabinsk State University. 2013. No 31 (322). Philology. Art Study. Issue 84. Pp. 126-135.
Rovovaya S.V. Printsypy, Predely, Osnovaniya Ogranicheniya Prav i Svobod Chelovela po Rossiyskomu Zakonodatelstvu i Mezhdunarodnomu Pravu. (1998). Principles, Limits and Bases of the Restrictions on Human Rights and Freedoms in Russian Legislation and International Law. Gosudarstvoi Pravo. No 8. – Pp. 41-45.
Schetinin B.V. Grazhdanini Sotsialisticheskoe Gosudarstvo. (1975). A Citizen and Socialist State. Sovetskoe Gosudarstvo i Pravo, No 2. Pp. 4-9.
Shundikov K.V. Printsypy, Predely, Osnovaniya Ogranicheniya Prav i Svobod Cheloveka po Rossiyskomu Zakonodatelstvu i Mezhdunarodnomu Pravu. (1998). Principles, Limits and Bases of the Restrictions on Human Rights and Freedoms in Russian Legislation and International Law. Gosudarstvo I Pravo.1998. No 8. Pp. 52-56.
Simonova N.V. Vzaimodeistvie Organov Publichnoi Vlasti na Territorii Prigranichnogo Subjekta Rossiyskoi Federatsii. (2009). The Interaction of the Public Authorities on the Territory of a Border Subject of the Russian Federation (based on the analysis of the materials of Western regional border agency of the Russia’s Federal Security Service) A PhD thesis (Law). Voronezh, 209 p.
Utyashev M.M. K Voprosy Ob Ogranichenii Prav Cheloveka. (2005). Revisiting the Restrictions on Human Rights. Pravovaya Politika i Pravovaya Zhizn. 2005. No 1. Pp. 113 - 114.
Vitruk N.V. Obschaya Teoriya Pravovogo Polozheniya Lichnosti. (2011). General Theory of Person’s Legal Status. Moscow. Norma, 326 p.
Belomestnyh L.L. Ogranichenie Prav i Svobod Cheloveka i Grazhdanina: Teoreticheskiy Aspekt. (2003). The Restrictions on Human Rights and Freedoms: a Theoretical Aspect. An PhD thesis (Law). Мoscow, 197 p.
Chetvernin V.А. Konstitutsiya Rossiyskoi Federatsii. Problemnyi Kommentariy. (2007). The Constitution of the Russian Federation. Comments to Difficult Points. Мoscow, 2007. 596 p.
Denisenko V.V. Legitimnost kak Kharakteristika Suschnosti Prava. Vvedenie v Teoriyu. (2014). Legitimacy as a Characteristic of the Essence of Law. Introduction to Theory. A monograph. Мoscow. Yurlitinform, 258 p.
Dolzhikov A.V. Kriterii Dopustimosti Ogranicheniya Osnovnykh Prav Cheloveka i Grazhdanina v Rossiyskoi Federatsii. (2003). The Admissibility Criteria of the Restrictions on Basic Human and Civil Rights in the Russian Federation. A PhD thesis (Law). Tyumen, 201 p.
Ebzeev B.S. Printsypy, Predely, Osnovaniya Ogranicheniya Prav i Svobod Chelovela po Rossiyskomu Zakonodatelstvu i Mezhdunarodnomu Pravu. (1998). Principles, Limits and Bases of the Restrictions on Human Rights and Freedoms in Russian Legislation and International Law. Gosudarstvoi Pravo. No 8. – Pp. 24-28.
Goiman V.I. Printsypy, Predely, Osnovaniya Ogranicheniya Prav i Svobod Cheloveka po Rossiyskomu Zakonodatelstvu i Mezhdunarodnomu Pravu. (1998). Principles, Limits and Bases of the Restrictions on Human Rights and Freedoms in Russian Legislation and International Law. Gosudarstvoi Pravo. No 8. Pp. 26-29.
Istomin V.T. Printsypy, Predely, Osnovaniya Ogranicheniya Pravi Svobod Chelovelai Grazhdaninapo Rossiyskomu i Mezhdunarodnomu Pravu. (2008). Principles, Limits and Bases of the Restrictions on Human and Civil Rights and Freedoms in Russian and International Law. The proceedings of the round table in the journal GosudarstvoiPravo. GosudarstvoiPravo, No 7. Pp. 26-33.
KabrievaT.Ya., Chirkin V.E. Teoriya Sovremennoi Konstitutsii. (2005). A Theory of Modern Constitution. Moscow. Norma, 237 p.
Kistyakovskiy B.A. V Zaschitu Prava. (1991). Defending Law (Intelligentsia and Legal Awareness). Vekhi: SbornikStatey o RusskoiIntelligentsii [Landmarks: A Collection of Papers about Russian Intellectuals]. Moscow. Pravda, Pp. 122-149
KonstitutsionnyePrava v Rossii, DelaiResheniya, (2002). Constitutional Rights in Russia: Cases and Decisions, A tutorial. Edited by А. Shaio. Мoscow, 459 p.
Lapaeva V.V. Problema Ogranicheniya Prav i Svobod Cheloveka i Grazhdanina v Konstitutsii RF. (2005). The Restrictions on Human Rights and Freedoms in the RF Constitution. Zhurnal Rossiyskogo Prava, No 7. Pp. 13-18.
Lebedeva E.N. Pravostimuliruyushaya Politika v Sovremennoi Rossii: Obscheteoreticheskiy Aspekt. (2014). The Policy of Legal Stimulation in Modern Russia: General Theoretical Aspect. Edited by A.V. Malko. Saratov. The publishing House of the Saratov State Academy of Law, 2014. 367 p.
Lepeshkin A.I. Pravovoe Polozhenie Sovetskikh Grazhdan. (1966). Legal Status of Soviet Citizens, Мoscow, 159 p.
Malinovskaya V.M. Pravomernoe Ogranicheniye Konstitutsionnyh Prav i Svobod Cheloveka i Grazhdanina v Rossiyskoi Federatsii. (2007). A Lawful Restriction on Human and Civil Rights and Freedoms in the RF. Мoscow, 217 p.
Malko A.V. Stimulyi Ogranicheniya v Prave. (1994). Stimuli and Restrictions in Law. Saratov, 259 p.
Matuzov N.I. Lichnost. Prava. Demokratiya: Teoreticheskie ProblemySubyektivnogo Prava. (1972). Personality. Rights. Democracy: Theoretical issues of the Subjective Law, Saratov, Pp. 189 - 205.
Nersesyants V.S. Progress v Prave, (1995). Progress if Law (historical experience и perspectives). Moscow. BEK, 1995. 302 p.
Novikova I.V. Sudebnay aZaschitakak Garantiya Realizatsii Konstitutsionnogo Pravana Mestnoe Samoupravlenie. (2004). Legal Defense as a Guarantee of a Constitutional Right on Local Self-government. A PhD thesis (Law). Voronezh. 2004. 191p.
NurmagombetovR.G. Konstitutsionno-Pravovye Zaprety i Ogranicheniya. (2007). Constitutional and Legal Prohibitions and Restrictions. An abstract of a PhD thesis (Law). Chelyabinsk, 33 p.
Pchelintsev S.V. Kontseptualnye Podkhody k Formirovaniyu Teorii Ogranicheniya PraviSvobod Grazhdanna Sovremennom Etape. (2006). Conceptual Approaches to the Development of the Theory of the Restrictions on Rights and Freedoms of Citizens at Modern Stage. Konstitutsionnoe I MunitsipalnoePravo, No 5. Pp. 23-29.
Pereverzev A.A. Osnovaniya Ogranicheniya Konstitutsionnyh Prav i Svobod Cheloveka i Grazhdanina v RF. (2006). The Bases for Restricting Human and Civil Rights and Freedoms in the RF.. An abstract of a PhD thesis (Law). Rostov-on-Don, 2006. 31 p.
Podmarev A.A. KontseptsiyanOgranicheniyanPrav i Svobod Chelovekai Grazhdanina v Konstitutsii Rossiyskoi Federatsii. (2011). The Concept of Restrictions on Human and Civil Rights and Freedoms in the RF Constitution, Moscow. Status, 329 p.
Pravai Svobody Cheloveka i Grazhdanina v Rossiyskoi Federatsii. (2005). Human and Civil Rights and Freedoms in the Russian Federation. Edited by Professor O.I. Tiunov, Doct.Sc. (Law). Moscow. Norma, 532p.
Romashova I.P. Legitimnost kak Kognitivno-Pragmaticheskaya Diskursivnaya Kategoriya. (2013). Legitimacy as a Cognitive and Pragmatic Category of Discourse. Bulletin of Chelyabinsk State University. 2013. No 31 (322). Philology. Art Study. Issue 84. Pp. 126-135.
Rovovaya S.V. Printsypy, Predely, Osnovaniya Ogranicheniya Prav i Svobod Chelovela po Rossiyskomu Zakonodatelstvu i Mezhdunarodnomu Pravu. (1998). Principles, Limits and Bases of the Restrictions on Human Rights and Freedoms in Russian Legislation and International Law. Gosudarstvoi Pravo. No 8. – Pp. 41-45.
Schetinin B.V. Grazhdanini Sotsialisticheskoe Gosudarstvo. (1975). A Citizen and Socialist State. Sovetskoe Gosudarstvo i Pravo, No 2. Pp. 4-9.
Shundikov K.V. Printsypy, Predely, Osnovaniya Ogranicheniya Prav i Svobod Cheloveka po Rossiyskomu Zakonodatelstvu i Mezhdunarodnomu Pravu. (1998). Principles, Limits and Bases of the Restrictions on Human Rights and Freedoms in Russian Legislation and International Law. Gosudarstvo I Pravo.1998. No 8. Pp. 52-56.
Simonova N.V. Vzaimodeistvie Organov Publichnoi Vlasti na Territorii Prigranichnogo Subjekta Rossiyskoi Federatsii. (2009). The Interaction of the Public Authorities on the Territory of a Border Subject of the Russian Federation (based on the analysis of the materials of Western regional border agency of the Russia’s Federal Security Service) A PhD thesis (Law). Voronezh, 209 p.
Utyashev M.M. K Voprosy Ob Ogranichenii Prav Cheloveka. (2005). Revisiting the Restrictions on Human Rights. Pravovaya Politika i Pravovaya Zhizn. 2005. No 1. Pp. 113 - 114.
Vitruk N.V. Obschaya Teoriya Pravovogo Polozheniya Lichnosti. (2011). General Theory of Person’s Legal Status. Moscow. Norma, 326 p.
Published
2018-04-30
How to Cite
Nintsyeva, T., Umarova, A., & Umarova, M. (2018). The theoretical and methodological bases of the institution of restrictions in the system of individual’s legal status. Amazonia Investiga, 7(13), 374-386. Retrieved from https://www.amazoniainvestiga.info/index.php/amazonia/article/view/577
Issue
Section
Articles
.gif)
