The present study was designed to make a
contribution to better understand optimal
instruction approached, by presenting findings
on how different instructional approaches can
support the developing reading comprehension
of the sketch construction project with principles
of a communicative-cognitive approach in
English by future civil engineers.
We address the following research questions:
1. How is English language lexico-
grammatical competence formed within the
context of a sketch construction project
within two instructional approaches in the
light of such communicative-cognitive
principles as information transfer and
reflection as metacognitive strategies
2. Which instructional approach leads to larger
gains in learning?
The rest of the paper is organized as follows: The
introduction presents and discusses findings of
the English language lexico-grammatical
competence content formation' stages and
groups of exercises with the usage of
informational transfer and reflection as a
metacognitive strategy. The Literature reviews
highlights two instructional approaches for
supporting the formation of the English language
lexico-grammatical competence of future civil
engineers. Methodology includes information
about participants and research instruments.
Results and Discussion present and discuss the
outcomes of the experiment and it is defined if
content domain or language domain approach is
better; highlight controversial issues about the
results of lexico-grammatical competence for
future civil engineers in reading. Conclusion and
limitations present summaries of the research
paper.
Theoretical Framework or Literature review
Several theoretical concepts of English language
lexico-grammatical competence including
lexical and grammatical knowledge, skills and
language awareness have been suggested in the
literature (Almarshedi, 2022; Palangan 2021). I
share the same English language lexico-
grammatical concept but point to the sketch
construction project as the context of its
formation and regarding civil engineers’
professional activity which demands
understanding of construction drawings.
Stages of developing competence have been
outlined by Shatilov, S. (Shatilov, 1986). He has
defined an oriented-preparatory stage, where
students get acquainted with new language
phenomena, followed by a stereotype-situated
stage, where the language skill is repeated by
multiple repetition. The final stage is the
variative-situated stage, when language skills
become more flexible in variable speech
situations. In the current project, we have
adopted this framework and implemented it in
the context of a sketch construction project: The
oriented-preparatory stage is directed at
acquaintance with new language material of the
sketch construction project; The stereotype-
situated stage is aimed at formation of receptive
lexico-grammatical skills on the level of word,
word combination, sentence in small and big
texts of the sketch construction project; The
variative-situated stage is directed at the
formation of lexico-grammatical skills on the
level of unity (the whole texts); In this final stage,
the goal is that students accomplish integrated
speech and reading skills.
In the current study, language exercises were
designed based on the stages outlined above.
Accordingly, four groups of exercises were
developed: 1) Oriented-preparatory stage
exercises focused on building acquaintance with
new language material, by using visual and
verbal supports, including marks of architectural-
constructive elements on the layouts of the sketch
construction project; 2) Exercises for the
stereotype-situated stage were designed to foster
receptive lexico-grammatical skills on the level
of word, word combination and sentence. To this
end, students were now presented with more
elaborate layouts with notes of the sketch
construction project and with linguistically richer
tables and descriptions of the construction
project 3) At the variative-situated stage,
exercises required students to comprehend even
larger text units, including descriptions of the
construction project and stages of
implementation 4) At the final integrative stage,
students practiced different levels of involvement
with the text, including skimming, scanning and
deep reading, based on the specific requirements
of the task at hand.
The suggested groups of exercises correlate with
the stages, which include subgroups of exercises.
A distinguishing feature in the construct of
lexico-grammatical competence for future civil
engineers is that they constantly refer to drawings
while doing tasks with notes for them and vice
versa. This means that the information transfer
principle is constantly evident in each stage. In
addition, reflection was also included after each
exercise and at the end of the group of tasks at
each stage. Thus, reflection tasks, in which